change in behaviour
t.d.lee at durham.ac.uk
Fri May 9 15:16:39 IST 2008
On Fri, 9 May 2008, Greg Matthews wrote:
> Installing MailScanner at a customer site on RHEL3 I noticed file
> locking problems. It seems the auto-detecting of required lock type
> (dependent on sendmail version) does not work in 4.68.8.
> When I manually set the lock type to flock, the locking problems
> Waaay back on this list there was much discussion about lock type and
> then Julian made MailScanner autodetect the required locking... am I
> misremembering? Anyway, 4.68.8 defaulted to posix whereas the previous
> version (4.50.15) autodetected correctly and worked with a blank "Lock
> Type ="
My own recollection (itself perhaps faulty) of the possible auto-detect
implies that you might be mis-remembering.
I think there were a couple of spates of discussion about the desirability
of autodetect, but I think the outcome was that there was no simple,
sure-fire reliable way for other software (e.g. the MS perl script) to
achieve, without fault, the auto-detection of locking-type in the host's
So I think the state for the last few years has been:
o no auto-detect;
o default OK for most modern OSes (modern sendmail) for most occasions
(but not "all OSes for all sendmail versions for all occasions");
o still an element of human-checking recommended.
Presumably Julian would welcome a contributed snippet of perl code that
really could reliably auto-detect all sendmail versions on any OS.
(Happy to be contradicted on this...!)
: David Lee I.T. Service :
: Senior Systems Programmer Computer Centre :
: UNIX Team Leader Durham University :
: South Road :
: http://www.dur.ac.uk/t.d.lee/ Durham DH1 3LE :
: Phone: +44 191 334 2752 U.K. :
More information about the MailScanner